Latest Clare Byam-Cook Scandal

Well, obviously everyone else has already addressed this more eloquently and amusingly than I can (see this blog post), but I feel the need to make a brief mention of the latest scandal over Clare Byam-Cook’s ahem, interesting, approach to breastfeeding.

Appearing on GMTV on a discussion about breastfeeding older children, C B-C  said “Breast milk beyond the age of 2 isn’t necessarily good because it’s very, very sweet. The fact that it’s breast milk doesn’t make it any different to a glass of Coca-Cola.” Once again demonstrating her phenomenal lack of knowledge related to both breastfeeding and child nutrition.

Since others have covered this topic so well, I would just like to run through a few quick points.

– Clare Byam-Cook’s credibility rests on her apparent qualifications as a midwife and ‘breastfeeding specialist’. According to the information on here, she ‘retired’ from practising midwifery in 1985 (a few short years after she must have started), and hasn’t practised, or presumably been licensed or done any further professional training, since. Her bio does not list, nor am I aware of, any actual training in breastfeeding support or management. Now, unfortunately, anyone can call themselves a ‘breastfeeding specialist’, and she’s certainly made a great deal of money trading as one and selling books on the subject, but it appears that she has no specialised training whatsoever, and any training she may have received as part of midwifery studies would now be at least 25 years out of date. Back in 1985, recommendations were still for routine separation of mother and baby, routine administration of artificial milk supplements, and scheduled feeding. So I guess that explains why she’s still promoting many such ridiculously outdated ideas. As ever, Clare Byam-Cook remains a shining example of why, when someone gives you proscriptive advice and claims to be an ‘expert’, you should never ever take them at face value!

Further to the specifics of this outrage, I’d like to say a few things about breastfeeding, breastmilk, and tooth decay.

– Sugar does not cause tooth decay, bacteria do. They are attracted to sugar on the teeth, and then wear away the enamel. More on that here
-Breastmilk does not contain the same sort of sugar that Coca-cola does – and lactose is not as attractive a sugar as sucrose/fructose for those sorts of bacteria
-In addition to sugar (lactose), breastmilk also has antibacterial properties that partially mitigate the effect of the sugar if you really want to, read more here
-Breastfeeding delivers the fluid differently than drinking out of a bottle or a cup. Drinking from a bottle or cup allows the liquid to pool behind the teeth, making it a prime ground for attracting bacteria to eat that tooth enamel. However, because of the way a baby latches onto the breast, breastmilk is actually delivered down the throat, bypassing the teeth entirely.
-Breastfeeding, even at night, even after toothbrushing, and even in older children is not associated with any increased risk of dental caries. In fact, ‘bottle-mouth-syndrome’ refers to artificially-fed babies plagued by caries.

For a fascinating, informative, and very graphic look at this issue, check out Brian Palmer, DDS

So, to sum up.
Breastfeeding. Does. Not. Cause. Caries.

Clare Byam-Cook is putting babies and mothers at risk with her insidious misinformation, and should be stopped. While I am titillated to see her stupid quote splashed all over the media, I am worried that this was all a ploy to get tons of press coverage… has she got a new book coming out?


Tags: , , , ,

7 Responses to “Latest Clare Byam-Cook Scandal”

  1. Muddling Along Mummy Says:

    I’ve had her *advice* promoted by several friends that breastfeeding past about 3 months has no value and I should stop because of returning to work – I’m just glad I chose not to listen to such an *expert* and did my own research, what worries me is how many people don’t question her views because she is touted as an expert

  2. tufftitties Says:

    Yes, and that’s why I started this blog in the first place – although there are plenty of other, more eloquent bloggers out there working hard to tell people the *truth* about breastfeeding, there is still so much misinformation, that I worry about the people who only hear the crap. It makes me so sad, and angry!

    I’m very happy to hear that you were able to ignore that and keep doing something of such incredible value for both of you 🙂

  3. Dispelling Breastfeeding Myths Says:

    Just wanted to let you know that I’ve linked to your blog on our FB page today – we’ve been discussing tooth decay, breastfeeding etc & I was reminded of the whole CBC nonsense. 😉 Thanks for a great blog!

  4. tufftitties Says:

    Thank you 🙂 someday i might manage to start updating it again!

  5. chevonne1 Says:

    would it be ok to post this article on my Breastfeeding Links Blog, This is a fantastic response to the Media slurs, and im sure my classes would be interested in the research behind the headline!x I am a student BFC for the NCT, so my blog only goes out to my students!x thank you for a brilliant post!x

  6. The truth Behind the Headlines Re Breast feeding and Tooth Decay…. « Chevonnes-Breastfeeding-Links Says:

    […] Tuff Titties blog response to The Media Headlines, Breastfeeding and Tooth Decay Share this:TwitterFacebookLike this:LikeBe the first to like this post. […]

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )


Connecting to %s

%d bloggers like this: